kinetosimpetus wrote:Hidden/Spoiler:
Clone Wars Season 3
Moderator: Moderators
-
- Sith Master
- Posts: 2631
- Joined: Fri Mar 27, 2009 10:23 am
- Projects :: Something cool...
- xbox live or psn: Has no xbox....Yup
- Location: Does whatever a Spiderpig does
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Hidden/Spoiler:
-
- Space Ranger
- Posts: 5557
- Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2010 3:30 pm
- Projects :: Evolved 2
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Darth_Spiderpig wrote:kinetosimpetus wrote:Hidden/Spoiler:Hidden/Spoiler:
I saw that too, I was excited and pointed it out to my dad.
- Eggman
- Master Bounty Hunter
- Posts: 1516
- Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 1:30 pm
- Projects :: Battlefront Chronicles
- Location: Las Vegas
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I thought the final two episodes were very well-done. The cinematics are getting better all the time.
-
- Sith
- Posts: 1400
- Joined: Tue Jun 16, 2009 3:20 pm
- xbox live or psn: SiulS2409
- Location: Costa Rica
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Yesterday was the first time that a seaon 3 episode was payed on latin america... pretty annoying to live here and being delayed on this series that was the first time i watched a season 3 episode...
- Jendo7
- Sith
- Posts: 1304
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2009 6:37 pm
- Location: Cambridge, England.
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I've only just got season two on blu ray, so I'm even further behind. Can't wait to watch it this weekend
-
- Captain
- Posts: 476
- Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:10 pm
- Projects :: Nothing--absolutely nothing
- Location: Freed by alien robots, now living on Mars
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I just watched the season finale.
SPOILERS
SPOILERS
Hidden/Spoiler:
Last edited by CalvaryCptMike on Thu Apr 07, 2011 8:31 pm, edited 2 times in total.
- Teancum
- Jedi Admin
- Posts: 11080
- Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2005 11:42 pm
- Projects :: No Mod project currently.
- xbox live or psn: No gamertag set
- Location: Indiana
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Who says the task force wasn't already in space when they received the distress signal?
-
- Captain
- Posts: 476
- Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:10 pm
- Projects :: Nothing--absolutely nothing
- Location: Freed by alien robots, now living on Mars
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Me.
I know, as I said the last four are just nitpicks that I noticed, they didn't take away from the finale as it was pretty cool. Just like the continuity errors in the original trilogy don't ruin it either.
I know, as I said the last four are just nitpicks that I noticed, they didn't take away from the finale as it was pretty cool. Just like the continuity errors in the original trilogy don't ruin it either.
-
- Space Ranger
- Posts: 5557
- Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2010 3:30 pm
- Projects :: Evolved 2
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
CalvaryCptMike wrote:I just watched the season finale.
SPOILERSHidden/Spoiler:
Sorry, your sadly mistaken if you think I am going to let this go untouched.
Hidden/Spoiler:
- Teancum
- Jedi Admin
- Posts: 11080
- Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2005 11:42 pm
- Projects :: No Mod project currently.
- xbox live or psn: No gamertag set
- Location: Indiana
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Ah, well now I know where to go when I want real world numbers on unexplained fictional phenomenon such as hyperspace travel. Unless you know how fast hyperspace travel is and how far apart these planets actually are I doubt you could make such an assumption.THEWULFMAN wrote:Hidden/Spoiler:
-
- Space Ranger
- Posts: 5557
- Joined: Tue Aug 17, 2010 3:30 pm
- Projects :: Evolved 2
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I am assuming this for the following reasons.Teancum wrote:Ah, well now I know where to go when I want real world numbers on unexplained fictional phenomenon such as hyperspace travel. Unless you know how fast hyperspace travel is and how far apart these planets actually are I doubt you could make such an assumption.THEWULFMAN wrote:Hidden/Spoiler:
Distance vs Speed, The exact speed isn't important. If they were far enough apart, where the hyperspace jump (Which, btw, consists of going into another dimension(Hyperspace)), would only last a minute, it would serve to easily explain away any mystery. It was made clear that Kashyyyk wasn't far. When I think of, not far, I think inter system.
Darth Maul took approximately seven hours to travel from Coruscant to Tatooine. That is halfway across the galaxy.
So am I an expert, no, do I have an idea as to what I am talking about, yes.
-
- Droid Pilot Assassin
- Posts: 2002
- Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2008 1:57 pm
- xbox live or psn: ScorchRaserik
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I think Tean's point was less, "you're crazy," and more, "you're arguing over the legitimacy of a children's science fiction TV show. Reality goes out the window, just enjoy the dang show." It's a kids show. It's fiction. The protagonists are going to win /somehow/ even if they are surrounded by depose on all sides in some desolate arena and Count Dooku is about to order their deaths. (U C wut I did thar?)THEWULFMAN wrote:I am assuming this for the following reasons.Teancum wrote:Ah, well now I know where to go when I want real world numbers on unexplained fictional phenomenon such as hyperspace travel. Unless you know how fast hyperspace travel is and how far apart these planets actually are I doubt you could make such an assumption.THEWULFMAN wrote:Hidden/Spoiler:
Distance vs Speed, The exact speed isn't important. If they were far enough apart, where the hyperspace jump (Which, btw, consists of going into another dimension(Hyperspace)), would only last a minute, it would serve to easily explain away any mystery. It was made clear that Kashyyyk wasn't far. When I think of, not far, I think inter system.
Darth Maul took approximately seven hours to travel from Coruscant to Tatooine. That is halfway across the galaxy.
So am I an expert, no, do I have an idea as to what I am talking about, yes.
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Yay , i can finally see episode 1,2,3 and 4 . And in french .
-
- Captain
- Posts: 476
- Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:10 pm
- Projects :: Nothing--absolutely nothing
- Location: Freed by alien robots, now living on Mars
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Hurray! Now you can rot your brain watching too much tv!!!
No, seriously good for you...
No, seriously good for you...
Hidden/Spoiler:
-
- Master Sergeant
- Posts: 174
- Joined: Fri Jul 09, 2010 3:49 pm
- Projects :: None
- xbox live or psn: UBERMEISTER32
- Location: Connecticut, USA
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Oh my gosh! I missed well over half of season 3. And just when I was getting optimistic, too. How does S4 look?
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Oh yeah , episode 5 and 6 available now in FR . Watching . I loved the 1,2,3,4 .
-
- Major
- Posts: 510
- Joined: Fri Jul 31, 2009 5:49 pm
- Location: Everywhere.
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I want to argue!
1) HOLD EVERYTHING!!!
...Ok?
2) It took the wookie task force 5-20 minutes to get on their ship, load their weapons, TRAVEL ACROSS THE GALAXY, find the transmitter that was sending the signal, THEN SOMEHOW KNOW WHERE CHEWIE WENT.
You're not taking into account the possibility that they weren't all the way at Kashyyyk then. Besides, given Kashyyyk is almost next door anyway, the only logical issue I had with that whole part was how, exactly, the transmitter was working at superluminal speed, but then I realized that they took parts from a starship, so it made some (a little) sense. We're talking interstellar travel, by the way. And the huge floating structure would be pretty easy to spot, and seeing a fight going on there would hopefully hint at something. You would easily be able to find the position on the planet, yes. There are GPS-type systems in Star Wars.
3) Do wookies have a sixth sense for knowing where chewie was?
I...laughed out loud...
4) The exact speed isn't important. If they were far enough apart, where the hyperspace jump (Which, btw, consists of going into another dimension(Hyperspace)), would only last a minute, it would serve to easily explain away any mystery. It was made clear that Kashyyyk wasn't far. When I think of, not far, I think inter system.
Basing off of real-world physics, which is all I can base it off of while being consistent, you'd be making a lot of assumptions. With real-world physics, going into "hyperspace" or "light speed" is simply travelling faster than the speed light waves travel through the neutrino aether. Kashyyyk wasn't far, correct. If the jump from one side of the galaxy to the other was achieved in a few hours, then given the proximity the jump from Kashyyyk to Trandosha would be much shorter, perhaps only a few minutes. You have to take into account obstacles and the distance, of course, and even then, two solar systems in close proximity to each other might be like our solar system and, say, Proxima Centauri - little to no obstacles aside from electrical interactions, which this civilization would have solved already, or they wouldn't be spacefaring. I think what hits the believability factor for most people is the fact that they can't comprehend the distance and are under the impression that the speed of light is supposed to be some kind of invisible limit.
Now that that's over with, I sortof enjoyed the last episode but something still bothers me about it. I don't know what, exactly.
1) HOLD EVERYTHING!!!
...Ok?
2) It took the wookie task force 5-20 minutes to get on their ship, load their weapons, TRAVEL ACROSS THE GALAXY, find the transmitter that was sending the signal, THEN SOMEHOW KNOW WHERE CHEWIE WENT.
You're not taking into account the possibility that they weren't all the way at Kashyyyk then. Besides, given Kashyyyk is almost next door anyway, the only logical issue I had with that whole part was how, exactly, the transmitter was working at superluminal speed, but then I realized that they took parts from a starship, so it made some (a little) sense. We're talking interstellar travel, by the way. And the huge floating structure would be pretty easy to spot, and seeing a fight going on there would hopefully hint at something. You would easily be able to find the position on the planet, yes. There are GPS-type systems in Star Wars.
3) Do wookies have a sixth sense for knowing where chewie was?
I...laughed out loud...
4) The exact speed isn't important. If they were far enough apart, where the hyperspace jump (Which, btw, consists of going into another dimension(Hyperspace)), would only last a minute, it would serve to easily explain away any mystery. It was made clear that Kashyyyk wasn't far. When I think of, not far, I think inter system.
Basing off of real-world physics, which is all I can base it off of while being consistent, you'd be making a lot of assumptions. With real-world physics, going into "hyperspace" or "light speed" is simply travelling faster than the speed light waves travel through the neutrino aether. Kashyyyk wasn't far, correct. If the jump from one side of the galaxy to the other was achieved in a few hours, then given the proximity the jump from Kashyyyk to Trandosha would be much shorter, perhaps only a few minutes. You have to take into account obstacles and the distance, of course, and even then, two solar systems in close proximity to each other might be like our solar system and, say, Proxima Centauri - little to no obstacles aside from electrical interactions, which this civilization would have solved already, or they wouldn't be spacefaring. I think what hits the believability factor for most people is the fact that they can't comprehend the distance and are under the impression that the speed of light is supposed to be some kind of invisible limit.
Now that that's over with, I sortof enjoyed the last episode but something still bothers me about it. I don't know what, exactly.
-
- Captain
- Posts: 476
- Joined: Sat Feb 19, 2011 3:10 pm
- Projects :: Nothing--absolutely nothing
- Location: Freed by alien robots, now living on Mars
- Contact:
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
I kinda got a similar feeling Too short maybe?Eaol wrote:Now that that's over with, I sortof enjoyed the last episode but something still bothers me about it. I don't know what, exactly.
Actually now that you guys have properly educated me in StarWarsGeekiIshNess I realize that the planets are next to each other andddd... during nasa's mars rover project they were transmitting signals from mars to earth at the speed of light and it took:
Hidden/Spoiler:
-
- Major
- Posts: 510
- Joined: Fri Jul 31, 2009 5:49 pm
- Location: Everywhere.
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Well I would like to point out is that the communication could have been in real time. You're assuming the use of radio signals, which won't get very far in the urgent time frame. Not all real-world signals and the like are limited to the speed of light.
Purely electrical communication, for instance ^-^.
Purely electrical communication, for instance ^-^.
-
- Droid Pilot Assassin
- Posts: 2002
- Joined: Sat Nov 15, 2008 1:57 pm
- xbox live or psn: ScorchRaserik
Re: Clone Wars Season 3
Well, you're right about the fact that electricity doesn't travel at the speed of light (aside from electromagnetic waves in a vacuum, which do, in fact, travel at the speed of light). Electricity is slower than the speed of light if moving through a medium.Eaol wrote:Well I would like to point out is that the communication could have been in real time. You're assuming the use of radio signals, which won't get very far in the urgent time frame. Not all real-world signals and the like are limited to the speed of light. false.
Purely electrical communication, for instance ^-^.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_of_electricity
Either way, you're still overlooking the fact that protagonists have the uncanny ability to overcome any obstacle no matter how many laws of physics it defies. Chewie + Ahsoka = protagonists in a kid's TV show (young adult's TV Show, if you must argue that point, too). That means that even if the odds were totally stacked against them in a way that it wouldn't be physically possible to escape/survive at all, the writers would find a way. Even if it means they both die and then wake up only to find it was all a dream, which quite frankly, seems like a pretty crap ending compared to a squadron of wookies flying in to save the day.
Bottom line, you people are looking WAAAAAYYY too far into this. Enjoy the dang show for what it is: fiction.